Please summarize the original results of the paper in your written report. This summary is essential for properly evaluating the paper. Also, please indicate if the paper contains results of potential interest to the general public, so that we could encourage the author to prepare a press release. Click here for detailed guidelines.

The paper is of public interest:

I rate the paper as:

(1) I find the paper acceptable in its present form.

(2) I find the paper acceptable with minor revisions described in my written report.

(3) The paper may be acceptable after important revisions. My written report describes my specific objections and suggests potential solutions. The revisions are expected to take no more than 4-6 weeks.

(4) The paper is not acceptable in its current form. My written report describes my specific objections and suggests potential solutions. The author should be encouraged to revise and resubmit the paper as it contains significant results and is expected to make an important contribution.

(5) The paper is not acceptable in anything resembling its present form. My written report describes my specific objections.

Please type/paste the text of your entire review here:

The assistance given by the referees is acknowledged at the end of each paper. The purpose of this policy is to encourage careful, constructive, and fair evaluation of papers submitted to JGR-Atmospheres. It also emphasizes to readers and authors that the material published in our Journal has been reviewed by competent scientists. Referees are therefore encouraged to agree to be acknowledged by name; however, they are not required or in any way pressured to do so. Please indicate your choice below.

I do agree to be acknowledged by name

I do not agree to be acknowledged by name

Name of Reviewer